Why Vonovia Is A Nice, European Actual Property Funding (OTCMKTS:VONOY)

Why Vonovia Is A Nice, European Actual Property Funding (OTCMKTS:VONOY)

Why Vonovia Is A Nice, European Actual Property Funding (OTCMKTS:VONOY)


Creator’s Notice: This text was initially printed on iREIT on Alpha on the twenty third of September 2022.

Expensive readers,

The time has come for me to replace my thesis on Vonovia (OTCPK:VONOY) (OTCPK:VNNVF). I final wrote an replace article a number of months again, with a base article again in April this 12 months, again when the Ukraine struggle was nonetheless a reasonably new factor. On the time, it was “barely a BUY”, as I mentioned in my article.

As we speak, it is a very totally different scenario, and I am allocating important capital to Vonovia.

Right here is why.

Vonovia – An replace.

So, the explanation why I like Vonovia are pretty elementary and ought to be simply understood.

It is one of many largest actual property corporations in all of Europe. It represents an oligopoly for the Berlin housing market. It is a BBB+ rated dividend stalwart with an excellent payout custom, and it is extraordinarily well-capitalized, with an outstanding asset portfolio stretching not solely throughout Germany, however together with Sweden and different nations as properly.

Vonovia IR

Vonovia IR (Vonovia IR)

As we speak the portfolio consists of almost 489,000 items in Germany, almost 40,000 in Sweden and 21,000 in Austria, to a complete of almost 550,000 items in extraordinarily tight rental markets.

Vonovia has among the finest capital buildings available on the market, and consequently borrows at lower than 2% curiosity on common, with a 50%+ charge of unencumbered belongings in FY2020/21. The corporate’s LTV ratio has been happening steadily, and is lower than 50% as of 2020/2021E, with a gross value of the gross debt trending downward as properly. LTV is, as of 2Q22, lower than 44%.

Level of reality, the corporate’s debt, and LTV ought to be even decrease, given the large reevaluation on the constructive facet Vonovia has been seeing. Nevertheless, regular M&A coupled with rising quantities of modernization CapEx in addition to a rising dividend has made sure that the corporate’s debt hasn’t gone down extra – and why we can’t see a lot change going ahead both.

All in all, Vonovia has no subject in any way funding no matter it deems crucial, and there aren’t any “main” gamers left on the German market to take over in its proximity.


As a result of Vonovia already owns most of them.

Bear in mind although, Vonovia is not a REIT. It is an ordinary firm. Actual property funding trusts (REITs) work in some international locations internationally. The USA has most of them. Nice Britain has some. Spain and France even have variations of them. Even Germany has what is named G-REITs – however Vonovia will not be a G-REIT.

What makes Vonovia such an ideal decide is the combo of the circumstances of its markets, and its valuation. I spoke at size about this in my unique article, so solely a brief recap right here.

The essential subject is that there is a large shortage of rental area (items), with present ranges at 100% dearer ranges than 10 years again, mixed with the components of:

  • An ageing inhabitants and family downsizing, requiring a better quantity of properties.
  • Robust migration waves in 2010-2020, requiring extra homes.
  • Urbanization.
  • Purchaser solvency/decrease rates of interest, pushing finish costs.

Vonovia’s place on this worth chain is specializing in essentially the most worthwhile cities, which has put the corporate in a scenario of having the ability to outperform. The view that there’ll “at all times” be a scarcity is after all improper. Nevertheless, the undeniable fact is that like Sweden, not sufficient properties are being in-built Germany to fulfill the demand, which signifies that this imbalance is more likely to stay for a while. Couple this with the easy incontrovertible fact that constructing new items prices an excessive amount of cash relative to the rents you cost, and you find yourself with new items costing much more in comparison with what at present out there items value.

There’s additionally the small matter that German tenant mobility is decrease than nearly wherever in Europe. As a consequence of inhabitants focus, jobs are available inside driving distance to most areas, not necessitating a transfer. Folks in Germany contemplate a drive from Hamburg to be a “lengthy commute” of round 30-50 km. The place I am from, a “lengthy” commute is something above 100 km. I at present journey 300 km each 2 days, and that’s not thought of all that lengthy right here both.

Bear in mind, the nation of Germany is smaller than the US state of Montana however homes 25% of the inhabitants of america, and is among the most vital western business nations in your entire world, properly forward of the US when it comes to industrial complexity (Supply:OECD).

Vonovia’s technique is to not “purchase low-cost and refurbish”. Moderately, it is to purchase the costly belongings out there available on the market and refurbish additional the place wanted, after which work with rents. This can be a phase of the market that requires an excessive amount of capital, which Vonovia has no scarcity of. This makes them a severe participant to deal with.

Which means that Vonovia has primarily historic zero vacancies (or round 0.1-0.5%, at present 2.2% with all belongings included), whereas new building begins are at extraordinarily low numbers total.

Now – dangers exist. Learn up on the way in which that Germany and Sweden total deal with landlords, and you may see what a few of the points are. The corporate’s historical past has been fraught with protests from tenant associations, unions, and politicians for each single deal they made.

Nevertheless, these points have been abating. Mietspiegel will increase for the 12 months have been true joys to see, with will increase properly above what I might have anticipated.

Vonovia IR

Vonovia IR (Vonovia IR)

What we see is important, for the reason that firm lower a web of 6,000 items for the reason that final article, that Vonovia performs at comparable/increased ranges, whereas having fewer items. Hire progress is 3.4% organically, and EBITDA, FFO, and group revenue metrics are displaying double-digit will increase on an adjusted foundation. LTV is at 43.3%.

Even on a Vonovia-stand-alone foundation, and with out the addition of DWNI, the corporate would have seen almost 10% income will increase and 4% EBITDA progress. That is spectacular, and in no way reflective of what we’re seeing in market developments.

Check out how the corporate has turned extra environment friendly over time in Germany particularly.

Vonovia IR

Vonovia IR (Vonovia IR)

The rental phase alone is ready to generate annual adjusted EBITDA of closing on €4B on an annual foundation, and the corporate’s working KPIs present no worries or points in any way – even with expensed/capitalized upkeep included. We’re seeing good natural lease progress, with nearly no vacancies because of demand. Vacancies Vonovia has are largely because of funding exercise, not as a result of individuals do not wish to lease.

Even with enter inflation and wage will increase, upkeep CapEx is near 2021 ranges. That is actually one thing it’s worthwhile to take into accounts right here.

And the lease is not the one factor that the corporate does. Vonovia additionally does VAP (Worth-added-Merchandise/Providers), that are at present at low volumes however nonetheless going robust. Sadly, any progress or efficiencies are at present being consumed by decrease bills in issues like Craftsman value financial savings, multimedia, residential setting, sensible metering, power, and different financial savings.

Vonovia additionally operates its growth phase, displaying elevated margins and quantity regardless of difficult KPIs and inputs. This phase is lots much less linear, traditionally talking, and 1H22 comprises giant to-sell tasks on the books, with round 1,088 items accomplished of which almost 600 might be bought.

Keep in mind that the political stress in addition to maintaining appearances forces Vonovia to divest a few of its newly constructed inventory. Regardless of this, the corporate noticed valuation progress in nearly all areas and markets throughout its portfolio.

Vonovia IR

Vonovia IR (Vonovia IR)

Some dangers, after all, exist. The elevated power costs are a serious one – as a result of they do not simply impression particular teams of tenants, however owner-occupiers and tenants who pay the supplier itself. It is a huge social problem that must be correctly discounted. Part of the corporate’s market growth may be defined by this. Particularly susceptible teams might be low-income households in homes with low power effectivity. Whereas a lot of the corporate’s portfolio is modernized (and its power effectivity is increased than the German common), it holds belongings on this class.

Within the second half, we now have the upper value of total capital. Nevertheless, with how well-capitalized this enterprise is, the corporate does not have instant funding wants. All financing want together with the funding program run by Vonovia is at present funded organically, placing Vonovia in an ideal place.

The vast majority of its growth to-hold tasks are being switched to promote, which except for garnering coverage/political favor, will notice money features beforehand booked as a non-cash features. The corporate can be rising its disposals of non-core and is dialing down CapEx after years of overspending on CapEx for a number of years in comparison with friends.

Vonovia has no M&A plans – which is logical given the final one.

Vonovia Leverage Policy

Vonovia Leverage Coverage (Vonovia IR)

Briefly, Vonovia seeks to monetize its platform by rolling out its service enterprise to 3rd events and turning into extra asset-light. It is also re-prioritizing capital allocation for a better rate of interest setting as is contemplating varied JV’s for efficiencies sake.

But the corporate’s monetary framework is iron-clad. As is the dividend paid by Vonovia. The corporate considers both fairness or debt as non-options right now. Nevertheless, all wants are lined, and 2022E steerage is now confirmed.

Vonovia expects at least €6.2B in income for the 12 months, with a 3.3% natural lease progress. Far below inflation, however very a lot in step with American REIT comps. Out of this income, the corporate expects to have the ability to pull a minimum of €2.75B in adjusted EBITDA, or €2.B in group FFO. The dividend coverage requires 70% of group FFO after non-controlling pursuits, which is at present forecasted to equate a dividend of round €1.8/share, implying a well-covered yield of 7%.

Let me reiterate that. That is a 7% yield, primarily near inflation, from the largest residential actual property firm in Europe, with environments with an extraordinarily tight market when it comes to residential provide.

I’ve no points with that.

Let me double-check the valuations with you.

Vonovia Valuation

In my final article, I made clear what I known as the “arithmetic of tears” – tears, on this case, being particular to the market valuing Vonovia at below €26/share. We use NAV comparisons, yield comparisons, public comps, progress estimates, e-book valuations, and earnings/money stream multiples. Bear in mind, that is not a REIT, so REIT-specific valuation metrics do not actually apply properly right here.

Friends are subsequently EU corporations alone. Buyers might wish to have a look at corporations like Covivio (OTCPK:FNCDY) and Icade (OTCPK:CDMGF), each French actual property corporations in comparable sectors. Outdoors we discover a entire slew of Scandinavian RE companies, comparable to Castellum (OTCPK:CWQXF), the most important holding in my whole present portfolio.

For friends, Vonovia at present affords a better dividend yield than the peer group, and most of its friends following the decline. At at the moment’s worth, the corporate’s 2022E dividend implies a yield of over 7%. This places its properly above Deutsche Wohnen’s legacy yield of three.26%, within the vary of Covivio, and above the legacy yield of Icade which pays over 7% (however can be far much less protected).

The basics stay the first arguments for investing in Vonovia. No peer has the dimensions, vertical integration, or place that Vonovia has. It trades at a P/E of under 10x for the native to a normalized GAP EPS. I might proceed to use a premium to Vonovia, however I am decreasing it to five% right here to mirror the upper rates of interest and elevated value of capital.

An ordinary assumption is that Vonovia is a “bond proxy”. This isn’t actually the case. Given its supply of an asset and earnings yield, the unfold between precise bonds and Vonovia’s earnings are as excessive as 7-8% traditionally.

Vonovia affords entry to one of the conservative, regulated residential markets on the planet, and I am not exaggerating once I say that that is most likely among the finest administration groups on this area in all of Europe. Bear in mind the steerage they gave half a 12 months in the past – that steerage is, even with every little thing, intact at the moment.

This power is the backdrop for my making use of a premium to the corporate’s valuation, permitting for a mixed PT of 1.1x (now not 1.2x) to a conservatively-calculated NAV and an honest P/E premium. On a median weighted foundation, my PT for Vonovia involves €48/share.

I am not reducing a cent from that new goal, regardless of the corporate having dropped so far as it has. I’ve made it very clear that I don’t shift my targets because of market temperament, and whereas I do decrease it some to account for aforementioned capital value will increase, I am unwilling to go a lot decrease than this.

S&P World involves the value vary of €42 on the low facet and €70 on the excessive facet, together with the consolidation with Deutsche Wohnen. Out of 17 analysts, 14 have both a “BUY” or “Outperformance” score on the corporate at a worth of €43.51/share. They’ve, for the reason that final article, elevated their total targets considerably.

I wish to emphasize that this firm holds over half one million items throughout Europe. This can be a very confirmed enterprise with an idea that works. It is one of many few gamers with the monetary muscle tissue in all of Europe to maneuver on these alternatives – and that is why I am eager to push my publicity right here. There’s an excessive amount of security available right here.

To these of you asking, “However US REITs appear higher”.

That is why my PT is €48/share.

Conventional US REITs have a particular benefit over Vonovia when evaluating them as investments. Nevertheless, for those who totally embrace Deutsche Wohnen’s portfolio within the firm, then the corporate’s present NAV involves 0.4X. There is a large low cost to Vonovia 2023E right here, and on condition that I do know precisely what kind of properties we’re speaking about, I do know I wish to personal them low-cost.

I am not keen to pay any worth. If this goes up above €60/share, I would reasonably purchase Realty Earnings (O) or different American REITs supplied FX goes again to being considerably extra favorable. However at this worth, that is the definition of advantageous diversification for me.

So – PT is now €48/share, and I am a “BUY” for Vonovia right here.


My view on Vonovia is as follows:

  • The biggest, most important actual property firm in all of Europe is at an ideal low cost taking a look at each single perspective you would probably contemplate.
  • Based mostly on its fundamentals and valuation, I view Vonovia as one of the actual property corporations in all of Europe. Coupled with its credit standing of BBB+, this makes it a “BUY” to me.
  • My goal PT is €48/share.

Thanks for studying.

Leave a Reply